Skip to content
OrbitSpot

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: Artemisia Gentileschi’s Dynamic Mary Magdalene.

One female figure throws her head back. Lids sealed, her mouth is closed, yet she is alert. With rosy cheeks and vermilion lips, her lustrous golden hair is illuminated by the light from a nearby candle, casting a incandescent aura in an predominantly gloomy space. Her attire includes a delicate blouse—falling off one shoulder to expose alabaster skin—to a heavy yellow and purple garment. Seemingly solitary, oblivious of any onlooker, existing in a state of profound freedom.

An Important Institutional First

This subject is Mary Magdalene “in ecstasy”, created in the seventeenth century by the renowned painter Artemisia. Freshly purchased by the prestigious institution in the U.S. capital, it is set to go on public view from 24 February. This marks the institution’s first purchase of a work by Gentileschi, and curator a leading scholar has written that it depicts the saint as “neither repentant nor suffering”. That represents an vital distinction, for generations, her representation has been formed not just by scripture but fabulated and conflated by powerful men.

“The most adaptable female figure in religious painting,” according to a expert observed.

Look at renderings of her and you encounter a reader, orator, disciple, and witness; crying at the base of the crucifix, washing Christ’s feet, or gazing heavenward—often atoning with pearl-like tears and, too often, exposing her bosom. Sometimes identified by a ointment vessel or a crimson garment—a contrast to the Madonna’s blue—she is commonly regarded nowadays as a romantic companion of Jesus, even though no biblical passage labeling her as such.

Deciphering the True Identity

“In reality, we cannot be certain who she was,” said the scholar. “So all these layers of interpretation have been placed upon her. The transformations she experiences, not just in art but in story, in worship, in doctrine, are as much related to cultural attitudes and theological shifts as they are to belief.” So what do we know?

Mary Magdalene appears in the Gospels 12 times. The first, she has evil spirits expelled from her; the rest, she is present at the crucifixion and is the primary witness to see his resurrection. It is she who proclaims the “good news”. Her sexual and immoral reputation can largely be linked to a homily given in the late sixth century by Gregory I, who confused her with another Mary and an unnamed sinner who washed Christ’s feet with her tears.

By lumping them into one, Pope Gregory effectively “invented” the repentant fallen woman—a myth further elaborated by subsequent theologians and Middle Ages texts. Artists took note, and in a predominantly illiterate but image-savvy world, this was influential. The “seven demons” morphed into the “cardinal vices”, establishing her dominant story as one of sexual fall and later salvation—concretised in artistic renderings that continue to influence perceptions today.

A Legacy of Suffering and Sexualization

From Donatello’s gaunt, wooden Magdalene clasping her hands in penitence, to Caravaggio’s seventeenth-century depiction of her drained of color and near death—not to mention yet another artist’s partially clothed, rapturous saint held aloft by angels. Her image has often been denigrated through objectification. Albrecht Dürer’s print showed her coyly, with flowing hair covering her nude body, while another’s version looks upward, with glassy eyes and carefully placed hands revealing her breasts.

Evidently, anguish and sexualization were the dominant extremes in her representation: she could serve as a warning against sin, be the exemplar for repentance, while providing artists a excuse to paint the female form masked as devotion. This “penitent prostitute” narrative endured for centuries—so profoundly that institutions called “Magdalene laundries” forced women into exploitative labor, a practice that astonishingly ended just 30 years ago.

Through a Woman’s Eyes

However, consider if there was another side to her narrative? What if her tale could be one of enlightenment and transformation, where she was pictured as full of life, delight, and sublimity? Essentially, what if we viewed her via the eyes of a female artist?

This is what Artemisia accomplishes. This portrait is not performing for the viewer; she is without tears, not repenting, without shame, not sexualized, and not preaching a sermon. Rather, she has rosy cheeks and is, as described, “passionately alive … in the grip of divine joy”. An expert stated that Gentileschi “endows Mary Magdalene with an electrifying life force”.

“It is an ecstasy painting, but it’s not her instant of conversion. It’s a moment of divine meeting … described sometimes as if it’s the finest sexual encounter … the greatest orgasm she could ever have. It’s aesthetic, it’s bodily, it’s sensual, it’s transcendent. You are raised outside yourself to a higher level.”

Frequently, when female artists depict scriptural or mythological women, they present them not as passive, sinful, shameful, or inferior, but as agentic, complex, and with minds of their own: “Women with a capital ‘Woman’”.

Part of a Broader Cultural Movement

Thus, while this recent acquisition may ultimately be correcting a gender imbalance at the institution, its importance runs deeper. It alters not just how we perceive religious and mythological women, but also the understanding of womanhood in general.

This view is one the Church eventually recognized. In 1969, it officially affirmed Magdalene’s official role as a faithful follower rather than a penitent sinner. More recently 2016, Pope Francis elevated her status to “apostle to the apostles”, designating a day in July as her feast day. It seems that, as institutions change, perspectives are transforming. This new purchase—portraying a figure liberated from a patriarchal gaze, existing for herself, without anguish and not exploited—is part of a greater movement towards equality.

The writer

Joanna Simmons

Elara Vance is an astrophysicist and science communicator with over a decade of experience in space research and public outreach.

OrbitSpot

Type to search articles.